{
  "date": "2026-10-22",
  "executed_utc": {
    "start": "2026-10-22T00:16:30Z",
    "end": "2026-10-22T00:32:24Z"
  },
  "question": "Which released recorder recipe produces the recording sets documented in the paper S5 Table, on the pinned model realization?",
  "result": {
    "all_16_counts_equal_S5": true,
    "ranks_agree": true,
    "spontaneous_set_equals": "param_spont (released)",
    "evoked_set_equals": "param (released; frozen in protocol-006)"
  },
  "counts": {
    "spontaneous|V1_Exc_L4": {
      "S5_spikes": 12128,
      "computed_spikes": 12128,
      "S5_analog": 400,
      "computed_analog": [
        400
      ]
    },
    "spontaneous|V1_Inh_L4": {
      "S5_spikes": 3467,
      "computed_spikes": 3467,
      "S5_analog": 399,
      "computed_analog": [
        399
      ]
    },
    "spontaneous|V1_Exc_L2/3": {
      "S5_spikes": 12176,
      "computed_spikes": 12176,
      "S5_analog": 400,
      "computed_analog": [
        400
      ]
    },
    "spontaneous|V1_Inh_L2/3": {
      "S5_spikes": 3487,
      "computed_spikes": 3487,
      "S5_analog": 398,
      "computed_analog": [
        398
      ]
    },
    "evoked|V1_Exc_L4": {
      "S5_spikes": 838,
      "computed_spikes": 838,
      "S5_analog": 62,
      "computed_analog": [
        62
      ]
    },
    "evoked|V1_Inh_L4": {
      "S5_spikes": 152,
      "computed_spikes": 152,
      "S5_analog": 22,
      "computed_analog": [
        22
      ]
    },
    "evoked|V1_Exc_L2/3": {
      "S5_spikes": 862,
      "computed_spikes": 862,
      "S5_analog": 80,
      "computed_analog": [
        80
      ]
    },
    "evoked|V1_Inh_L2/3": {
      "S5_spikes": 173,
      "computed_spikes": 173,
      "S5_analog": 26,
      "computed_analog": [
        26
      ]
    }
  },
  "populations": {
    "V1_Exc_L4": 37500,
    "V1_Inh_L4": 9375,
    "V1_Exc_L2/3": 37500,
    "V1_Inh_L2/3": 9375
  },
  "param_spike_set_overlap_with_param_spont": {
    "V1_Exc_L4": {
      "param_also_in_param_spont": 836,
      "param_total": 838
    },
    "V1_Inh_L4": {
      "param_also_in_param_spont": 152,
      "param_total": 152
    },
    "V1_Exc_L2/3": {
      "param_also_in_param_spont": 856,
      "param_total": 862
    },
    "V1_Inh_L2/3": {
      "param_also_in_param_spont": 173,
      "param_total": 173
    }
  },
  "seeds": {
    "pynn_seed": 5,
    "mozaik_seed_in_parameters": false,
    "mozaik_seed_effective": 513
  },
  "mpi_ranks": 16,
  "code_path": "Fig4.png is written only by perform_analysis_and_visualization_spont (called only by run_spont.py; README pairs it with param_spont/defaults).",
  "inference": "The published Figure 4 statistics were most likely computed from the param_spont recording set (S5 Table, code path, released instructions and Figure 4G bounds). Counter-evidence: the archived param run lists a Fig4 image with blank metadata, and Methods section 4.3 text describes central recordings whose totals equal the evoked set. The authors run record is unavailable.",
  "consequence": "Protocol-006 (param) would compare a different, much smaller sample with Figure 4. Keep protocol-006 unchanged; version a new protocol with param_spont.",
  "new_neural_simulation": false,
  "attempts": {
    "attempt_01": "failed in Mozaik CLI parsing (unquoted results_dir); no model code ran",
    "attempt_02": "passed"
  },
  "limits": [
    "Positions and recorder selection only; no connectivity or dynamics",
    "Figure 4 recipe is inferred, not recorded",
    "Methods text on 190 central analog neurons interpreted as describing evoked protocols"
  ],
  "full_model_run": "pending",
  "biological_validation": "pending",
  "token_control": "pending",
  "figure_4g": {
    "method": "Smallest plotted density h_min in the published Figure 4G log-log panels; released code uses numpy.histogram(density=True) over 20 bins of 0.2 log10 units, so N >= 5 / h_min.",
    "bounds": {
      "V1_Exc_L4": {
        "h_min": 0.004261,
        "N_min": 1173,
        "N_min_one_pixel_error": 1089,
        "param_spike_recorded": 838,
        "param_can_produce": false
      },
      "V1_Inh_L4": {
        "h_min": 0.004344,
        "N_min": 1151,
        "N_min_one_pixel_error": 1067,
        "param_spike_recorded": 152,
        "param_can_produce": false
      },
      "V1_Exc_L2/3": {
        "h_min": 0.002494,
        "N_min": 2005,
        "N_min_one_pixel_error": 1860,
        "param_spike_recorded": 862,
        "param_can_produce": false
      },
      "V1_Inh_L2/3": {
        "h_min": 0.002886,
        "N_min": 1733,
        "N_min_one_pixel_error": 1607,
        "param_spike_recorded": 173,
        "param_can_produce": false
      }
    },
    "conclusion": "The param recorders cannot have produced the published Figure 4G in any population."
  },
  "data_volume": {
    "spike_trains": {
      "param_spont": 31258,
      "param": 2025
    },
    "analog_neurons": {
      "param_spont": 1597,
      "param": 190
    },
    "cost_measured": false
  },
  "model_files_check": "receipts/model-files-check.json: 37/37 match contract (dated re-check; pre-probe check output not retained)"
}
